South Africa’s era of prolonged loadshedding between 2022 and 2024 brought with it unique societal shifts, one of which was the emergence of informal pointsmen. These untrained individuals took to directing traffic at busy intersections, earning tips in exchange for their efforts. However, as the country surpasses 200 days without planned power cuts, many of these informal pointsmen have seen their income streams dry up.
In the bustling suburb of Fourways, Johannesburg, motorists have begun noticing a troubling phenomenon: traffic lights seemingly disabled during the day only to function again at night. Residents suspect foul play, pointing fingers at some of the very individuals who once sought to ease their commutes.
MasterDrive Weighs In
Eugene Herbert, CEO of MasterDrive, raises concerns about the legitimacy and safety of these practices. “No official confirmation has been issued to validate these suspicions,” says Herbert. “But regardless of whether these claims are true, drivers should exercise extreme caution when dealing with illegal pointsmen.”
Unlike their official counterparts, informal pointsmen lack the training and authority to safely manage traffic flow. “South Africa’s busiest intersections are complex and dangerous,” Herbert explains. “Untrained individuals directing traffic can significantly increase the risk of collisions and chaos.”

The City’s Stance
The City of Johannesburg has responded firmly to reports of illegal pointsmen. Motorists are advised against tipping these individuals, as doing so may perpetuate the issue, particularly if suspicions about tampering with traffic lights prove accurate.
Yet, the situation isn’t always straightforward. Some reports indicate that illegal pointsmen can become aggressive or even violent when denied tips. To mitigate risks, motorists are encouraged to take the following precautions:
- Limit Stationary Time: Anticipate traffic conditions to avoid unnecessary stops.
- Maintain Distance: Leave ample space between vehicles to reduce vulnerability.
- Secure Valuables: Keep windows closed and belongings out of sight.
- Avoid Confrontation: Allow authorities to handle illegal pointsmen and refrain from engaging in negative interactions.
Navigating Intersections Safely
Motorists are reminded to critically assess the directions of anyone attempting to manage traffic without proper authority. “Even trained pointsmen acknowledge the elevated risk of accidents under manual direction,” Herbert states. “Drivers should never proceed through an intersection with blind trust, regardless of who is directing traffic.”
Instead, approach every intersection as if traffic lights are out of service, treating it as a four-way stop unless an official pointsman is present. Herbert advises drivers to adopt a cautious mindset: “Slow down, check all directions, and anticipate the actions of other drivers, particularly those ignoring traffic norms or directions.”
Striking a Balance
While outright ignoring illegal pointsmen is ideal in theory, the reality is often more nuanced. In situations where other motorists are following their guidance, ignoring their instructions can create more hazardous conditions. “In such cases, it’s crucial to follow the flow of traffic while maintaining heightened caution and vigilance,” Herbert explains.
Each scenario demands its own approach. The key, according to Herbert, lies in informed decision-making. “While some illegal pointsmen may act with good intentions, they lack the authority and expertise needed to safely manage traffic. Ultimately, the safest course of action is to treat intersections without operational lights as four-way stops whenever possible.”
As the debate over informal pointsmen grows, one thing is clear: motorists must prioritise safety above all else. Whether dealing with suspected tampering or navigating intersections under manual direction, remaining vigilant and cautious is critical. In a system where unofficial actions blur the lines of authority, every driver’s decisions carry the weight of responsibility—for themselves, their passengers, and fellow road users.


Comments
Newest firstLoading comments…